Compare Rowing Machines

127 responses to “Compare Rowing Machines”

1. 

   DEBBIE

   March 4, 2013

   I am interested in the fitness degree fitness e-520 or atlantic water rowers. Have you done a review on either of those as they compare to other rowing machines?

   thanks,
   debbie

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      March 4, 2013

      Hi Debbie,

      I have not reviewed the FItness Degree Fitness E-520 or any Atlantic Water Rowers thus far. Depending on the type of machine, the number of reviews on other sites, and if I can get access to the machine, a review can take me anywhere from a few days to over a week to complete.

      I am working on the comparison table of rowing machines as we speak and I’m hoping to have it done soon. I can pull information on the rowers you want more information on and add it to the comparison table if that would help but, it would take me some time, however, to write a full review. Let me know if that would help.

      Thanks!
      Edwin

      Reply
2. 

   DEBBIE

   March 5, 2013

   thanks! looking forward to your new comparison table.

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      March 7, 2013

      Hi Debbie,

      In my opinion, adding the Fitness Degree Fitness E-520 or any Atlantic Water Rowers to this comparison table won’t be enough to help you. I can research the rowers (most likely I won’t be able to write a review just yet) and let you know some details about the machines.

      If you don’t mind, I have a few questions:

      1) Which machines would you like me to compare the above rowers to (and did I review any of them yet)?
      2) How’s your fitness level right now?
      3) Have you used a rowing machine before?
      4) How many people will be using the machine you ultimately decide to buy?
      5) Do you have a resistance type in mind (it appears you’re sold on water resistance) and if so, why?

      Thanks!
      Edwin

      Reply
3. 

   evan

   July 13, 2013

   I was looking at the Body Rower BRW7200 is this a good machine? Also I am having a very difficult time finding a retail store to buy it or to even try it out before I buy on Line…Live in So Cal, Los Angeles area, any review or location advice?

   Thanks

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      July 14, 2013

      Hi Evan,

      I haven’t reviewed the Body Rower BRW7200, but based on some preliminary research, it appears it isn’t that solid of a machine.

      There are complaints about the performance monitor display and the build quality of the machine, the issues with the build quality are what bothers me most.

      If you’re looking for a magnetic rower because it’s quiet and requires low maintenance, I would look into the Velocity Fitness Magnetic Rower (I reviewed this rower and it’s a very popular rowing machine). It’s a solid rower and isn’t too much more in price compared to the Body Rower.

      As far as trying it out in person before you purchase, the only thing I would be concerned about is my height – if you’re shorter than 6’4″, you shouldn’t have any issues with using the rower whatsoever. Unfortunately, nowadays it’s a little difficult to try out rowing machines from a local store as most of them don’t have showrooms for you to try them out.

      I live in San Diego and fortunately, there’s a place not too far away from me that has a lot of rowers in their showroom. I’m sure you can find one in LA, but it may require some searching. I did a quick google search but couldn’t find anything.

      Like I said though, the main reason I would want to try a rower in-person is if I’m tall (~6’4″), otherwise you’ll be fine. Please let me know if you have any other questions and thanks for stopping by!!!

      Edwin

      Reply
4. 

   Steven Cole

   August 11, 2013

   Hi,
   I just wanted to alert you to what is probably an error. You list the weight of the LifeSpan RW1000 as 25lb, which seemed absurdly light to me. I did some research on the web, and saw that Walmart says that the shipping weight for the RW1000 is 80lb, which seems a more probable weight. (Amazon also says that the weight of the RW1000 is 25lb, which is probably the origin of the mistake.)

   Steve

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      August 11, 2013

      Hi Steven,

      Thank you so much for letting me know about the apparent error. I was also skeptical of the weight initially, but I know there are a few rowing machines out there that look heavier than they actually are (in retrospect 25 pounds does seem very light).

      I remember checking the manufacturer’s website, but they didn’t have any information on the weight so I decided to go with Amazon’s given weight. Big mistake, I already caught at least 2-3 errors on Amazon’s site.

      I’m going to contact LifeSpan about the weight for the RW1000. Thanks again for letting me know, Steven.

      Edwin

      Reply
   2. 

      Edwin Murray

      August 12, 2013

      Steve,

      FYI, LifeSpan just got back to me and told me the weight of the machine is 80 pounds. I’m going to update the weight information on the website right now. Thanks again for bringing this to my attention.

      Edwin

      Reply
5. 

   Miguel

   August 13, 2013

   Edwin, i am planning to buy a rower for my apartment. I like the Concept2 reviews (very complete and a lot of videos), and the Kadett Outridger (no much information) . I would like to know if the quality of exersise done in Concept2 is the same that the one done at the kettler. Also how durable are the cocept2 part (air chamber, etc). Also were i can find a video on the Kettler Kadett Outrigger Style Rower Rowing Machine.. Thanks

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      August 13, 2013

      Hi Miguel,

      I’m sorry that the level of information you’re seeking on the Kadett Outrigger is not as thorough is not as you would like. Is there something in particular you needed to know about the Outrigger that I didn’t cover? If so – please let me know.

      However, I did create a video for the Kettler Kadett Outrigger, here’s the url of the video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLL6RU1rSq4

      Regarding your questions about the Concept2 (I’m assuming you’re referring to the Model D), the quality of the machine is actually better than the Outrigger, it also requires less maintenance because it is an air resistance rower compared to the Outrigger which is a hydraulic piston.

      The durability of the Concept2 is a definite strength of the machine, I see “beat up” machines all the time that take years and years of abuse – you can tell people abuse them (like the ones at the gym) – HOWEVER, each component of the Concept2 is still going strong including the air chamber, handle, seat, PM monitor, it’s just an overall solid rowing machine. You can’t go wrong with it.

      If I had to pick between the Concept2 Model D (or E for that matter) or the Kettler Kadett Outrigger, I would definitely go with the Concept2.

      You did mention it’s for your apartment. Are you on a top floor or bottom floor? The Model D does make a little noise because of the flywheel, however it isn’t bad at all to be honest with you.

      Just keep in mind, if you’re on the top floor it might irritate the tenants underneath you. If that is the case, let me know and I will recommend another rower for you.

      Edwin

      Reply
6. 

   Miguel

   August 14, 2013

   Edwin, thanks for you answer. Yes i am in a 12th floor, and space is a concern. What about the Velocity Fitness CHR-2001 Programmable Magnetic Rowing Machine vs. Kadett. My price top is up to $1,000, so all this rowers are within my budget. Is the Velocity magnetic a durable machine, I ask since it has one of the lowest warranties of the top group. What parts are more propense to go wrong in the velocity and do you know if there are expensives? Thanks again for your help. Miguel

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      August 14, 2013

      Hi Miguel,

      Since you’re on the 12th floor of an apartment complex, you want to avoid a fairly noisy machine so I would pass on any air resistance rower, including the Concept2 Model D I mentioned earlier.

      The Velocity Fitness Magnetic Rower is a really good rowing machine and it’s durable. It’s unfortunate that the warranty isn’t better but based on my research and talking to a few owners, the rower is solid and runs for years without any major issues.

      The parts in the Velocity Fitness that are most prone to giving you issues (like other magnetic rowers) are the magnetic braking system that provides the resistance. If it gives you issues it will be expensive to fix. It doesn’t break too often, in fact I haven’t heard from anyone yet that complained about the braking system breaking down and I talk to/ research A LOT.

      The Kadett is a good rower, Kettler is a solid company, and they provide a solid warranty.

      If I had to pick between the two (Velocity Fitness and the Kettler), I would go with the Kadett because of the better warranty.

      Normally, I would pick a magnetic rower over a hydraulic piston rower because a magnetic rower requires less maintenance (for example, hydraulic pistons need to be replaced in a few years) but Kettler is a solid company and you can’t go wrong with their quality.

      It’s a close call, but Kettler Kadett would be 1A, Velocity Fitness Magnetic Rower would be 1B.

      Please let me know if you have any other questions.

      Thanks!
      Edwin

      Reply
      1. 

         Miguel

         August 15, 2013

         I just found about the Kettler Coach M Indoor Rower (~$1,000 in Amazon.com), but it is not in you review list. Can you tell me about this rower? The have also the Kettler Stroker Rower and Multi-Trainer (~$700 IN Amazon.com) and the Kettler Premium Magnetic Rower – Black (AXOS ) but I can not find it in the USA (only UK). Will you know something about the Kettler Stroker Rower and Multi-Trainer (Item model number: 7982-500). Thanks again for you time and recommendations

         Reply
         1. 

            Edwin Murray

            August 18, 2013

            Hi Miguel,

            I have not reviewed the other Kettler rowers you are inquiring about (yet). As of this reply, I have reviewed the Kettler Favorit and Kettler Kadett. Based on your budget and living situation, I would choose a magnetic rower, a “higher-end” hydraulic piston rowing machine such as a Kettler-branded rower, or a water resistance rower. Based on your previous inquiry, I suggested the Kettler Kadett. You really can’t go wrong with that rowing machine. However, because you have a high budget, I have one other recommendation for you and it’s the WaterRower A1 Home Rowing Machine, I recently reviewed the rower here:

            https://rowingmachineking.com/waterrower-a1-home-rowing-machine-review/

            I would choose the WaterRower A1 over the Kadett because it’s beautiful, nothing beats the realistic and fluid rowing motion of a water-resistance rower… and it’s a WaterRower – a very solid rowing machine brand. WaterRower’s are usually priced above your budget but this model is priced under your budget and not much was ‘lost’ on this model compared to the pricier models.

            Take a look at the WaterRower A1 review if you haven’t already and let me know if you have any other questions.

            Thanks,
            Edwin

            Reply
   2. 

      Kylie Croker

      October 12, 2020

      Hi, I am looking at purchasing a rower for my husband. We are looking at a commercial grade rower, my problem is my husband is very tall, 6.6 with long legs. His leg length is 98cm. We are finding it difficult to find measurements on the actual seat to foot length. Are you able to help?

      Reply
      1. 

         Edwin

         October 12, 2020

         Hi Kylie – If your husband is 6’6″ then I would look at the Concept2 or Xebex for air rowers and WaterRowers for water resistance. There are a lot of other factors to take into consideration like price and resistance but once you narrow it down, the manufacturer can also give you inseam length recommendations.

         Reply
7. 

   Barbara

   March 18, 2014

   I am between buying a Concept2 model D (6-7yrs old)
   Vs the Lifecore R100 (2 yrs old never used)
   Both priced same price lifecore is about 1 hr drive closer. Its for my 16 yr old daughter who is on Crew. Any thoughts?

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      March 18, 2014

      Hi Barbara,

      That’s awesome that your daughter is in crew. Ideally, I would like to know what the condition of the Model D is before I answer but I’ll just go ahead anyways. I would go for the Lifecore R100 because it’s an awesome machine (like the Model D) and it’s unused – I’m concerned the Model D wasn’t taken care of properly.

      The Lifecore is a commercial machine so it will last a life time and it will provide your daughter the training she needs for crew. It can also be used by others for a great cardio workout while building some lean muscle.

      You really can’t go wrong with either choice, but I would go for the Lifecore – plus it’s an hour closer to you…

      Good luck with the rower – I’m sure your daughter will love it.

      Thanks for stopping by,
      Edwin

      Reply
8. 

   Laura

   March 23, 2014

   Hi! First some praise, then a question.
   When I discovered how much of a stress reliever a rowing machine is for me I decided I had to have one at home and couldn’t just use the one at the gym since I don’t make it there as often as I’d like. I stumbled on your site looking for reviews and information on rowers and I have to say, I used your info obsessively during my search for one to purchase. Love it and love this chart! I checked craigslist daily (good rowers seem to sell in less than 24 hours), amazon, used stores on weekends and sporting goods stores that stocked rowers. Amazon was useful but I always came back to your page for more comprehensive info. I lost out on an older used concept 2 and a used ProRower H2O RX 750 yesterday that sold quicker than I could look at them and ended on a new A1 Water Rower that I found at a fitness store that had 1 in stock. So thank you so much for all the info! I know I made a good purchase.
   My question is about working out on the rower. I’m not new to rowing (I am new to rowing more regularly) and I think my form is ok. But I’m looking for weight loss and general fitness. I’m not in shape but I’m strong. Can you direct me to any sites that have good info on good rowing machine work outs? I found a couple last night that mentioned rowing slower for weight loss. I don’t think I push myself too hard but my average is probably 30-32 spm, this site recommended 20 spm because at that rate you’re burning fat and at faster rate you burn carbs, but 20 spm feels slow to me. The articles I found quickly were mostly small articles publised in various fitness magazines. I do gas out semi-quickly at 30 spm, but 20 feels like not much effort. Any direction you could point me or recommendations you might have to share would be most appreciated!
   Thank you so much for all the help you’ve already provided me! :)

   Laura

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      March 24, 2014

      Hi Laura,

      Thank you for the kind words about my website.

      You had to do a little hunting, but I’m glad you were able to track down a great rowing machine and the WaterRower A1 is definitely a great one!

      As far as different workouts on a rower in general, the most effective for me (by far) have been mixing in HIIT with my rowing workouts.

      HIIT stands for high intensity interval training and can be done with practically any cardiovascular exercise; especially rowing machines!

      Here’s a link to how you can mix in HIIT with your rowing workouts:

      http://www.menshealth.co.uk/fitness/cardio-exercise/3-high-intensity-workouts-to-burn-fat-and-increase-fitness

      It may sound intimidating at first, but after a while you will get the hang of it and it burns SO MUCH FAT and CALORIES!

      Literally, your body is burning calories for HOURS after your workout is done.

      Mix HIIT in with your current routine.

      Here’s a link to an article that talks about how to start a rowing routine on your rower: http://www.livestrong.com/article/73112-rowing-machine-workout-plan/

      When I start rowing this is how I develop a “routine”; I pick a target whether it’s row for 30 min, 60 min, 10k meters, etc and hit that target for 3x during the week. Then, next week, I add a little more to the previous week’s goal, usually 10%. And then keep adding an extra 10%+ the following weeks.

      And then, I would add HIIT, etc. to mix things up even more and to keep my body “guessing”.

      I hope I didn’t jump all over the place and I gave you some ideas for how to develop a rowing routine. In short, there are a million ways to start a rowing routine, it’s just up to you what you ultimately choose and when you increase your time/ distance/ reps, make sure you don’t jump up too high or you will burn out fast and won’t want to row for a few weeks (happened to me before).

      Let me know if you need additional help. Congrats again on your new rower!

      Edwin

      As far as your ‘regular’ routine,

      Reply
9. 

   Scott

   June 22, 2014

   WaterRower Oxbridge Rowing Machine vs. Kettler Kadett Outrigger Style Rower

   Hey Edwin,

   Price difference aside, which one of these two rowers would you consider the better machine?

   Thanks,

   Scott

   Reply
   1. 

      Edwin Murray

      June 28, 2014

      Hi Scott,

      Sorry for the late reply. Hands-down, the WaterRower Oxbridge Rower is the better of the two. It has the better resistance type (Water; most realistic and the resistance is variable)… I could go on-and-on, but you can never go wrong with a WaterRower.

      Let me know if you have any other questions Scott and thanks for stopping by.

      Edwin

      Reply
      1. 

         Nicole

         September 21, 2020

         Hello, I have watched reviews that mention a big belly as an issue with a Water Rower. Does this apply to every model or for that matter every straight rower or is it really not a big issue?

         Reply
         1. 

            Edwin

            September 23, 2020

            Hi Nicole – I don’t think it’s a big issue and it would be a general rowing machine issue, not just a specific model.

            Having a big belly could affect the rowing stroke but it easy to test. I would just sit on the floor in some of the different rowing positions (legs straight out, legs bent and leaning forward slightly). If any of these positions feel too awkward then maybe a rowing machine isn’t the best piece of equipment.

            Reply
10. 

    Bill

    October 16, 2014

    WaterRower vs First Degree Fitness Viking.
    Which one do you prefer?

    Thanks

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin Murray

       October 18, 2014

       Hi Bill,

       I haven’t reviewed the Fitness Viking rower yet so I can’t answer your question thoroughly. However, I heard some really good things about the Viking rower so keep that in mind. If I had to choose between the Fitness Viking rower or an equivalent WaterRower machine, I would have to go with the WaterRower because they’re one of the first rowing companies to manufacture wooden rowers – they’re experts in that category and you want to choose the more solid machine. I’m sure the Viking rower is a solid choice too – but get the better of the two options and that’s a WaterRower. Let me know if you have any other questions. Thanks for stopping by, Bill.

       Reply
11. 

    Bob

    July 12, 2015

    Hi Bill,

    Other than the wood type and color, why the difference in ranking for the various WaterRower models?

    Thanks

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 14, 2015

       Bob,

       Over the years there have been changes made to the models such as monitors and pricing. I will have to go back and rerank the machines based on the current conditions. Currently the Natural, Club, Oxbridge, and Classic are all mechanically the same with different wood finish.

       Sorry for the confusion and thank you for bringing it to my attention!

       Reply
12. 

    Yoon

    August 15, 2015

    Hi Edwin,

    I am planning on getting a rowing machine to lose weight. I can’t afford the high end machines, so I wanna buy the stamina air power 1399. Would you recommend it? and do you think it will give me the exercise I need to lose weight? If not, is there a better option for <$500?

    Thanks.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 17, 2015

       Yoon,

       Yes, I definitely recommend the Stamina Air Rower 1399. It is one of the best selling rowing machines and it will provide you with a great workout to lose weight.

       I hope you enjoy it!!

       Reply
13. 

    Umair

    August 19, 2015

    Hi Edwin,

    Thanks for the awesome website. I have a question: what is your opinion of Apollo Ap-601h rowing machine? I am tempted to buy it but have found no credible review of the machine on the internet.
    I will appreciate your help.
    Thanks!
    Umair

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 19, 2015

       Umair,

       What country are you located? It doesn’t look like this rower is offered in many countries which is probably why there are no reviews. I have not personally come across this rowing machine or found a site that provides enough information so it’s hard for me to give an opinion. What site were you going to purchase it from?

       Reply
14. 

    Sarah

    November 26, 2015

    Hi, Thank you for your great site. I live in France and want to buy one for my husband who used to be a rower (Lake Geneva) and my son (a boxer). (And for me, but that’s a secret.)

    I can pay up to 400euros but the ones you mentioned are not on Amazon France.

    Here are some of the ones in that price range:
    V-Fit AR1 Artemis 2 Air Rameur
    V-fit Rameur Air Tornado
    Skandika Regatta Oxford Pro
    Hammer Cobra Rameur
    BH Fitness Boston Rameur
    Powerpeak Energy Line Rameur
    Skandika Regatta Pro 5 Neptun
    Rameur Rameur Favorit Kettler
    AsVIVA Cardio XI Rameur ergomètre

    Thanks for your advice. I do want to get something my husband won’t scoff at.

    Sarah

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       November 27, 2015

       Hi Sarah,

       Thank you for the compliment! :) That is very nice of you to be buying a rower for the family! Seeing that your husband and son are both athletes, I would definitely choose an air rower. They supply the most resistance and are the rowers of choice for athletes.

       With that being said, it narrows the rowers you have selected down quite a bit. Going through all the rowers I would choose either the V-fit Rameur Air Tornado or the V-Fit AR1 Artemis 2 Air Rameur. Both seem like very solid rowing machines and are the best rowers in this price range. I would read the reviews on both and choose which one you like better. Both are great!

       I hope this helped and enjoy your new rowing machine!! Let me know if you need anything else :)

       Reply
       1. 

          sarah

          November 28, 2015

          Dear Edwin,
          Thank you for your advice! I’ll go for the Air Tornado. Will definitely stay tuned to your website.

          Reply
15. 

    Tina

    December 3, 2015

    Any thoughts on the LifeFitness Row GX trainer?? https://www.lifefitness.com/facility/products/gx-series/row-gx

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       December 4, 2015

       Tina,

       Looks like a nice rower and after reading about it a little it seems like it would be a great machine. How much would you be purchasing the machine for and from what distributor?

       The LifeFitness Row GX is very similar to some of First Degree Fitness’s Rowers. You can check out different user reviews on Amazon to get a feel for how people like them and compare pricing by clicking here.

       Also, check out my reviews on other water rowing machines here. Let me know any information you can so I can help point you in the right direction and make the best decision! Thanks for the comment!! :)

       Reply
16. 

    Carol

    February 14, 2016

    Please help – I have a long term ankle injury and can only exercise sitting down. I’ve found the best machine for me is a rowing machine. But I want to buy one for home use but my budget it max at £300 (preferably a bit less). It also needs to fold away and not be too noisy.
    Last Christmas I got a York for about £250 – it broke within 3 months and so was sent back (It also arrived with a damaged seat which was quickly replaced).
    I’ve spent ages searching reviews on the internet but they all have such conflicting reviews – some people say they’re great then others talk about their disastrous experiences – it’s very off putting as they are not easy things to get rid of once you’ve bought them (I have a cross trainer that I can’t use and can’t get rid of).

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       February 15, 2016

       Hi Carol,

       I understand your pain and I’m sorry to hear that finding a good rower has been difficult for you. With everyone having their own unique preferences it can be hard to choose a great rower that fits your needs. What is good for some may be bad for others. Hopefully I can help steer you in the right direction! :)

       So your preferences are less than £300, foldable storage, and not very loud. (By the way, I am not extremely familiar with all the UK brands but I will do my best). Looking at all of the rowers it seems like the magnetic Marcy rowing machines would be a good fit for you.

       Marcy Regatta Folding Rowing Machine
       Marcy RM413 Henley Magnetic Foldable Rowing Machine

       Both machines have great reviews, are under £300, foldable, and magnetic so they won’t be loud. If you want you can also go to the Amazon Top Seller list to see what some of the top selling rowers are. You can then narrow down your search by price, foldable storage, and resistance (magnetic, air, hydraulic piston, water). I have an article about the 4 rowing resistance types if you want to read.

       Also remember that people are always more likely to go online and leave a negative review than a positive one. Just think that most people who receive a great rower use it and are happy while people who receive junk are angry and want to let the company know.

       If you need more help please feel free to leave another comment or send me a personal email! edwin@rowingmachineking.com

       Reply
17. 

    Sharlyn

    February 27, 2016

    Hello,

    This is a wonderful source/website! Please advise thoughts on Nordic Track RW200 Rower. Seems like a rower is the right start to getting in shape. Thanks, Sharlyn

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       February 29, 2016

       Hi Sharlyn,

       Thank you for the wonderful compliment! I have not reviewed the Nordictrack RW200 so it is tough for me to make a recommendation. I will look into this rower if you can give me some of the following info: Where will you buy the rower from? How much $$? How did you find this rower and why did it peak your interest?

       I am asking these questions so I can try to give you the best advice possible or advise on a different rower. The Nordicktrack RW200 is a fairly new rower which is sometimes a scary thing because the company has not worked out all the kinks and initial malfunctions that can happen. I would usually advise on getting a rowing machine that has a long track record of positive reviews from happy customers :) but depending on your circumstances it could be the right rower for you!

       Always glad to help so just let me know!

       Reply
18. 

    Diane

    March 3, 2016

    I’m looking to purchase a rower and have been considering the Stamina 1215. Is it a good choice? Do the free motion arms make a difference? Thanks for you input.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       March 3, 2016

       Hi Diane,

       Yes the Stamina 1215 is a great rower, especially if you are looking for a hydraulic-piston rower (my top choice). If you are going to purchase a hydraulic-piston rower then I like to have the free motion arms. This gives you the ability to mimic rowing on water and also targets different muscles by being able to row at different angles.

       If you want an air rower I would look into the Stamina Air Rower 1399. Here is a link to my article about the difference between an air rower and hydraulic-piston.

       If you already know you want a hydraulic piston rower then you have picked the right one! If you are unsure about the resistance type I would read my article about the different options.

       Thanks and let me know if you have any questions!

       Reply
19. 

    Lisa

    May 12, 2016

    Hi Edwin,

    I need help choosing a good rowing machine for me. I think I’ve read too many reviews on different kinds of rowers so now I can’t decide anymore. I’m looking for one that’s less than $500, not loud, lasts long and won’t break down easily, doesn’t take up space, but will help me burn fat and get a good workout. I’m looking to purchase from a site that can deliver like amazon. Thanks for your help.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       May 12, 2016

       Hi Lisa,

       I know how tough it is to choose a rower and it seems like the more you read the more confused you get! Hopefully I can help point you in the right direction.

       Normally I tell people to purchase the Stamina Air Rower 1399. I feel it is the best rowing machine under $500 and I even wrote an article about it here or you can check out my full review of the rower by clicking here. My only worry is that you mentioned you wanted a quiet rower. Air rowers are not known to be quiet but it just depends on how much noise you can deal with? In my opinion they are worth the noise.

       If you opt out of getting an air rower you are then limited to getting a magnetic or hydraulic piston rower. The best magnetic rower under $500 is the Lifespan Fitness RW1000 (see review here) and the best hydraulic piston rower is the Stamina 1215 Orbital Rower (see review here).

       I would choose between those 3 based on your preferences. I believe the Stamina Air Rower is the best because it provides the highest resistance and has less mechanical parts that can fail but it is the loudest of the 3.

       I hope I was able to help and if you have any other question please ask. Just give me as many details as possible so I can help find the perfect rower for you. Good luck!!

       Reply
       1. 

          Lisa

          May 12, 2016

          Thanks for the awesome suggestions! Can you send me the link where I can order through your site? I will take a look at the three you suggested but most likely I will choose the first one you mentioned since you know a lot more about them than me. I don’t mind the noise as long as it’s not crazy loud. I just want to be able to hear my music or movie through headphones. LOL

          Reply
          1. 

             Edwin

             May 12, 2016

             Awesome, yeah you will have no problem with headphones on. You can order through this link here.

             Thank you so much and I hope you enjoy your rower! Let us know how it works out for you :)

             Reply
20. 

    Jenny

    May 30, 2016

    What do you know about the NordicTrack RW200 Rower? I have the NordicTrack spin cycle and am very happy with it.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       May 30, 2016

       Hi Jenny,

       I have not reviewed this rower but I have come across it a few times. NordicTrack usually makes great equipment so I’m sure it is a great machine.

       Before I gave you a recommendation I would need to know: Where will you buy the rower from? How much $$? What about this rower peaked your interest?

       Thanks for the comment and I look forward to your reply!

       Reply
       1. 

          Jenny

          May 31, 2016

          Hi Edwin,

          Initially, I was interested in the NordicTrack Rower because I have a NordicTrack spin bike and grew up exercising on the NordicTrack skier. Today, I’ve done some more research and think I want the Stamina Air Rower. I want to mix up my workouts between spinning and rowing. The price tag on the Stamina rower is attractive. What are your thoughts on the Stamina Air Rower? I’ll buy from Amazon prime.

          Reply
          1. 

             Edwin

             May 31, 2016

             Hi Jenny,

             That is exactly why I was asking those questions! haha. I wanted to see if your preferences matched up with the Stamina Air Rower.

             For people who are looking to spend under $500 on an air rower I always recommend this rower. I even wrote an article, if you want to read, about the best rowing machine under $500. You can also click to check out my full Stamina 1399 Review

             Please let me know if you have any questions about purchasing this rower and as always, thanks for the comment! :)

             Reply
21. 

    Alana

    June 20, 2016

    Are any of these rowers recommended for weight capacities over 330 lbs?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       June 21, 2016

       Hi Alana,

       I know I spoke with you already through the Concierge Service Page but I will reply for other visitor reading this.

       The Concept2 Model D has a 500 lb weight capacity and is the best rowing machine overall in my opinion.

       Also, most of the WaterRower models are rated for weight up to 1,000 lbs.

       Thanks!

       Reply
22. 

    Jill Alperstein

    July 26, 2016

    I am wondering why more rowers don’t have an oar-type system, as appose to a single bar and pulley system. Does this make a difference? I am looking trying to find a system with a wide hand position that would engage the more central back muscles, as in real life. It seems that it would be more fun, comfortable, and beneficial.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 27, 2016

       Hi Jill,

       I know I responded to this in your email but I will answer for other readers as well.

       From my experience there are not a lot of “great” rowing machines with the oar function because in order to get that movement the resistance has to be hydraulic-piston. Hydraulic-piston rowers may mimic the “rowing motion” closely but they feel the least like rowing on water. On hydraulic-piston rowers you set a resistance level and the level stays the same no matter how fast you row. This is the opposite of how resistance acts while actually rowing on water. When rowing on water, the faster you row, the more resistance is created between the boat and water, and the harder it is to row. This type of resistance is exhibited by air and water resistant rowing machines, which is why they are very popular.

       When Olympic athletes train on rowing machines they are not looking to perfect their “oar” technique. Their technique work is done in a scull. So a rowing machine is used to train their rhythm, speed, power, endurance, etc.. This is best done on an air rowing machine, specifically the Concept2 Model D.

       I hope this answer helps!

       Reply
23. 

    Lou

    July 31, 2016

    My name is Lou. I am 71. My legs are extremely weak. what type of physical equipment would you recommend to restore strength to my legs . Thanks

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 1, 2016

       Hi Lou,

       I know I answered your question via email but I will answer again for other readers.

       Rowing machines are perfect for building leg strength as a perfect rowing stroke should use about 60% legs, 20% core, and 20% arms. They are also very low impact which makes them great for building strength and avoiding injury.

       If you need help narrowing down your search visit my Start Here Page or ask me via the Personal Rowing Machine Concierge!

       Reply
24. 

    Steve

    October 13, 2016

    I ordered a Lifecore R90(good price) rower, but there are no reviews online anywhere. Do you have any info in this rower?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       October 14, 2016

       Hi Steve,

       What info are you looking for on this rower? Sorry I have not done a full review on it but have done one for the R100 and R88. LifeCORE provides great rowing machines but they just live in the shadow of the Concept2 rowers in the U.S.. Mainly because they are priced similar but the Concept2 has a better monitor and is more widely used.

       You can read the LifeCore R90 webpage for most of the info. Also if you already ordered it then there really isn’t much left to research that won’t be figured out on your first session. There is a 30-day money back guarantee if anything goes wrong so that is very comforting.

       Hope you enjoy your new rower! I’m sure it will perform well, so if you are happy with the price it should be a great purchase!

       Reply
25. 

    Lisa

    December 1, 2016

    Hi, I filled out the Personal Rowing Machine Concierge a few days ago. How long does it take to get a response back for that?

    Thanks,
    Lisa

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       December 1, 2016

       Hi Lisa,

       I almost always respond within 24 hrs unless I can’t be at my computer for some reason.

       I responded to a Lisa on Nov 22nd but it was to “lisao18914@yahoo.com”(i will delete later). Is this you? If not, I did not receive the form.

       Did you get a follow up email? I have an auto-responder that goes out after you submit it. Also check your spam box in case it got sent there.

       Sorry for the inconvenience but let me know if any of these are the issue. If not I’ll send you a personal email.

       Thanks

       Reply
26. 

    MaRee

    January 3, 2017

    I am looking at the Concept2 D/E vs. Waterrowers. Two Adults for at home use, alternately with other gym machines. I like the look and size of the wooden product, but ultimately just want the smoother better machine…opinions or thoughts?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       January 3, 2017

       Comparing the two can be tough because each has their own benefits. The WaterRowers will have a slightly smoother stroke and will be quieter than the Concept2’s.

       The Concept2 will have a better monitor and the damper settings will allow you to adjust the feeling of the rowing stroke to be heavier or lighter.

       I like to say that the Concept2 is for fitness enthusiasts who like tracking their data. They are the top choice for Crossfit gyms and training Olympic rowers. WaterRowers can also be used to train hard but are better for using while watching TV and in a living room setting.

       If you are looking to buy the best rower for hard workouts/training I would choose the Concept2. If you want a quieter, more aesthetically pleasing rower then go with the WaterRower.

       Either way you will be getting a top of the line rowing machine.

       Reply
       1. 

          MaRee

          January 3, 2017

          I have watched a few videos of the Concept2, is it really that loud? Or is it fairly loud and you could still use it when your kids are in bed?… its quite hard to get an idea when you hear it in a small room or gym setting. Noise might very well be the choice tipper of these two models.

          Reply
          1. 

             Edwin

             January 4, 2017

             It’s hard to say about the noise level because what is considered loud to one person is different from another. The C2 is fairly loud and it depends where you will be rowing in the house compared to where your kids bedroom is located. If you are in the next room it is possible that they could hear it and wake up. If you are down a hall or on another floor then no I don’t think the noise will travel that far.

             Depending on where you live, if you call a few local gyms they should have a Concept2. You could go there and ask to hear how loud it is and I’m sure they would let you test it.

             Reply
27. 

    Roger

    August 17, 2017

    I have seen the video and your review of the Stamina 1110, it looked very good with the 60″ frame, I question the short length,you report it a con. I will use the bike for muscle maintenance not muscle building. What effect does a short frame have on exercise. Have you reviewed the Sunny SF-RW5634?. Thank you,Roger

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 17, 2017

       Hi Roger,

       Sorry if I was not clear in my review but I did not say the shorter overall length is a con (60″). I say the shortened strong length due to the handle not being able to fully extend forward is a con.

       Not being able to fully extend forward means you cannot complete a full rowing stroke. For some, this may not be a problem because they are not very flexible and cannot extend very far forwards anyway.

       For others, it will feel very uncomfortable not to be able to extend all the way forward. Especially for people who have rowed before.

       Sorry but I have not reviewed the Sunny SF-RW5634 yet. Hopefully in the near future I will get a chance.

       Please let me know if you need anything else!

       Reply
       1. 

          Roger webb

          September 4, 2017

          Edwin,If you like to do business with a company that has good costumer service don,t buy a Stamina 1110. That is another “Con” for the stamina 1110. I may have a problem with the meter. I called the Costumer service an hour after it opened. A recording said “leave model and serial number for service. I held a dead quiet phone to my ear for 5 minutes then heard a recording for an operator press “0” then a recording said “leave your name and number we will call tomorrow” I would not recomend that machine or business to anyone. .
          Roger

          Reply
          1. 

             Edwin

             September 6, 2017

             Hi Roger,

             Sorry to hear about your bad experience. Please send me an email if I can help in any way.

             I have dealt with Stamina before and should be able to get in contact with them.

             Reply
28. 

    Mohammad

    November 3, 2017

    Hi. I am working on a school project looking at user accommodation of different indoor rowers. I am wondering if there is any information on the “width” across the handles.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       November 4, 2017

       Hi Mohammad,

       Sorry but there usually isn’t any information on handle width. You would have to call each manufacturer individually and ask for the handle width of each model.

       Reply
29. 

    Vlad

    November 13, 2017

    Hello,

    I’ve been working on a Matrix Air Rower in a hotel’s gym this weekend and it’s needless to say how awesome that machine is : stability, several levels of difficulty… When got back home, searched on the internet and it seems that Matrix Air Rower is about 2000$ which I can’t afford… Do you guys have any option similar to that one in terms of stability and levels of difficulty but with a more realistic price (under 1000$?) .

    Thanks in advance.
    Vlad

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       November 13, 2017

       Hi Vlad,

       I believe you mean the Matrix “Magnetic” Rower and not “Air” Rower. Unfortunately, there are no magnetic-only rowers that are comparable to the Matrix for under $1,000.

       You can check out the Stamina Avari Magnetic Rower, which is the bestselling magnetic rower under $1,000. See my review here.

       You can also check out the Concept2 Model D which is the #1 bestselling rowing machine overall and an air rower. See my review here.

       If you aren’t concerned with noise level the Concept2 is the best rowing machine overall in my opinion. It is used in all Crossfit gyms and by Olympic athletes.

       Reply
30. 

    Chris

    January 17, 2018

    I am hoping that concierge form got to you but I can’t see Nything in sent email – if not can I email this site?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       January 17, 2018

       Hi Chris,

       Once you hit the send button at the bottom of the form it should say “message sent”. I have received a few submissions today so it should be working.

       You can send the answers directly to my email (Edwin@rowingmachineking.com) if it isn’t working for you.

       Reply
31. 

    David

    February 28, 2018

    Edwin,

    I’ve been thinking about buying a rowing machine lately and decided to dig in and learn more about them today. I stumbled upon your site and found it to be helpful and informative — especially your table “Compare Rowing Machines”. Your site (and a few others) helped me conclude that if I was to have only one fitness machine at home, a rower would be a fine choice. Which left me with the question — which machine?

    Now, I don’t row in the water and probably won’t but, it didn’t take me long to notice the curious and interesting differences between static and dynamic machines. My top three selection criteria are sturdy build quality, wanting an effective/efficient workout per time invested, and minimal risk of injury. Given the information reviewed, I was leaning toward a static/air machine but, the more I read about dynamics, well, the muddier the water became. Where the main advantage of a dynamic machine seems to be an on-the-water feel for competitive training, I found several other differences and considerations on the web. Certainly, I don’t want to overthink it all but, was less than ready to pull the trigger based on what I’d learned today.

    So, I thought I’d leave a reply on your site and suggest a refinement of your table to include a sortable column for static/dynamic machine types along with an expansion of your reviews to include a few more dynamic machine examples. I found two dynamic machines that seemed noteworthy (in my humble). Would you consider including the dynamic machines made by Oratec http://www.oartec.com/ and Rowperfect http://www.rowperfect.ca/? Comparing those two with the Concept2 Dynamic would enrich the comparison of dynamics alone and adding their other attributes would strengthen the comparisons of the other static machines as well.

    Thanks again for putting up your site.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       March 1, 2018

       Hi David,

       Thanks for the reply! I do have an article about the difference between static and dynamic ergs that you can read here.

       I would love to include reviews of all the dynamic ergs but I really just don’t have the time right now. Some people also stay away from dynamic ergs as they are more expensive and also a bit more difficult to use.

       I may be reviewing the Oartec in the near future and will reach out when I do!

       Thanks for your feedback!

       Reply
       1. 

          David

          March 9, 2018

          Edwin,

          Again, I really appreciate your site, your guidance and your quick response given the demands on your time. I read your article on the difference between static and dynamic machines. I’ll also look forward to your Oartec review.

          In my case, cost of the equipment isn’t the primary concern — especially as compared to the ultimate cost to recover from a potential injury. Concern for potential injury (already have issues with knees and back) is probably driving my curiosity in a dynamic machine.

          In that regard, I’d be interested in your comments to the information published by Rowperfect regarding the potentials for injury to knee’s, back (and brain) from a static machine: http://www.rowperfect.ca/documents/RP17kg.pdf

          All the best,

          David

          Reply
          1. 

             Edwin

             March 9, 2018

             Hi David,

             No problem, I definitely enjoy your interest in both machines and hopefully you’ll be able to give me some insight into your findings.

             While the argument in the Rowperfect PDF is logical, you also have to understand it is a piece of marketing material for their rowing machine.

             I can definitely see their case in regards to additional pressure on the knees from a static erg. Basically, rowing machines in general are very low impact and are far better than running and other activities. If you are comparing static vs. dynamic ergs, then yes, dynamic ergs would be even more low impact than static ergs.

             As far as head injuries go, I just don’t buy it. They are basically saying that every single activity would cause brain damage. Jumping rope, walking, driving a car on a bumpy road. Basically we are all doomed according to their article haha. I understand the research and concern around CTE but some studies basically say we can’t do any activities. No water skiing, riding dirt bikes, playing soccer, etc.

             If money isn’t a concern, I would definitely try out a dynamic erg. They do have a lot of benefits over static ergs and the only downsides are they take a bit longer to learn to use and are more expensive. The cost factor is usually the biggest deal and the reason most people don’t buy them.

             Reply
32. 

    Matt

    May 18, 2018

    Do you think this water rower on amazon is a good budget choice? Reviews look good. Sunny Health & Fitness Water Rowing Machine Rower w/ LCD Monitor – Obsidian SF-RW5713

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       May 18, 2018

       Hi Matt,

       Yes, I think it is the best budget water rower. I think it has less quality issues than the Stamina 1445. I’m actually currently working on a review of the Obsidian now!

       Reply
33. 

    Peter Bartonek

    July 29, 2018

    Hi Edwin
    Do you know anything about the Endurance R300 Rower?
    I haven’t been able to find any reviews on it at all.
    Or is it worth paying the extra to go to the Concept 2 or something..
    Im looking to buy a rower ASAP and this one is being sold at a local retailer.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 30, 2018

       Hi Peter,

       Unfortunately I don’t have any experience with it due to it being very new to the market. I would test it out at the local retailer to see if you like it.

       A big thing to compare would be the monitor on the R300 vs the Concept2

       Reply
34. 

    Andrew R

    September 26, 2018

    Hello-

    I’m not sure if you still monitor this page, but it’s a great resource.

    I have a two-year-old Kettler Stroker that I use and…fairly tolerate. It doesn’t seem very reliable in terms of calculating distance or calories (well, kilojoules since it’s German), and I can’t track my workouts very well. I was on crew in college and my first experience with rowing was on a Concept 2. I’d like to start looking for another machine. Noise and resistance type aren’t an issue; I’d prefer not to break the bank; and I’d prefer foldable if possible. I have the real estate for the length of the Concept, but it’d be a struggle.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       September 28, 2018

       Hi Andrew,

       Yeah, I’m not a huge fan of hydraulic-piston rowers because they normally have some quality issues. The Kettlers are by far the best in this category though.

       If you are looking for the best rower then the Concept2 is the go to model. You can fill out my form here and I can send over a few option via email: https://rowingmachineking.com/personal-rowing-machine-concierge/

       Reply
35. 

    Jay

    September 30, 2018

    Hi, I wish to buy a rowing machine mainly for my son who is 13 and in the school rowing crew and as a exercise equipment for the rest of us ( my daughter of 21 who was a rower and my husband and myself who are regular exersise doers. I am from Sri Lanka and hence the choice is limited i guess. We have BH ( rowing circuit R550, LK580 Profesional Rower, R590 Professional Rower) Concept @ Model D and another brand called Quantum. Most are magnetic resistance systems. Your kind advise on a purchase would be most welcome.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       October 1, 2018

       Hi Jay,

       If you have the option to buy the Concept2 Model D then that will be your best option. It is the best rowing machine for training purposes and is the most used model by people who row on the water.

       Reply
36. 

    Jay

    October 3, 2018

    Hi, thank you very much for your response. what is your opinion on “Indoor Rower RW1000 – Life Span / USA” please. It is much cheaper

    Reply
37. 

    John

    December 27, 2018

    I am looking at a rower for weight loss, fitness, and moving towards actually sculling. I have used gym rowers, and each one at the gym uses the short pull-handle with a line to give resistance. I am thinking that a Full Motion rower, which uses the long handles to emulate the oars on a scull, would be a better prep machine for my goal. Plus, the short pull-handle seems to me to be restrictive and not as natural. I also think that an available incline would assist. Please give me your comments. Thanks.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       December 27, 2018

       Hi John,

       I would actually have to respectfully disagree with your assessment. The rowers you see in a gym are probably the best for weight loss, fitness, and practicing for sculling.

       While they may not have the exact sculling motion, the resistance will be “variable” resistance and most similar to the resistance of sculling. All Olypmic rowers will use an air rower with the same handle attached to a chain that you see in fitness centers.

       You want to focus on good rowing form on the rower but the actual feathering techniques, etc. will be practiced on the water. The hydraulic-piston rowers that have the 2-handles are also not as good as the air or water rowers.

       Based on your comment, I think the Concept2 or a low cost air rower would be the best fit for you.

       Hope this helps!

       Reply
38. 

    Mariam

    March 26, 2019

    Hi I’m looking for a rowing machine. I’m not too worried about noise. I just want it to grow with me. So I need to strengthen my core because I have back issues as well as strengthen my back for posture because neck issues. I like your review but I see the list above might be a little out dated and there are newer machines. I’m looking for something under $500. Maybe $300 range is preferable.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       March 27, 2019

       Hi Mariam,

       Please fill our my rowing concierge form so I can give you a more detailed reply.

       Thanks :)

       Reply
39. 

    Jacob

    May 13, 2019

    So where is the concept 2 d review, this is just a con, a bunch of affiliate links in the table, you are supposed to provide a review, I clicked on your website from google because it said concept 2 review pffft this shouldn’t be allowed…your number 1 on the google search and there’s no review lol googles going down hill!!

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       May 13, 2019

       Hi Jacob,

       I actually had to temporarily remove my review due to a concern with copyright issues in my photos. I’m currently updating my review and will be posting again later this week.

       I can assure you it is not a scam and I can guarantee my reviews are more legit than another other website. I actually own and use a Concept2 and have tested a large number of the rowers I review. If I am not able to test the models, I reach out people who have for their opinion and use my experience from using many different types of rowing machines to write the review.

       I’m sorry for the inconvenience but I had no choice but to take the reviews down for the time being.

       Reply
40. 

    Christa McDaniel

    August 19, 2019

    Have you heard any input on the Schwinn Crewmaster Rower?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 20, 2019

       Hi Christa – unfortunately, I have not gotten the chance to review it or find someone who has one to get an honest opinion. I have it on my list for a future review.

       Reply
41. 

    John Tipton

    October 22, 2019

    Hi I am looking at investing in a rowing machine. I am thinking of an air style. There is one on Amazon by MaxKare Air Rower but other then Amazon reviews I can not find out any other information and company or the rower. Do you know if they are a good company and make a good machine.
    Thank you

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       October 23, 2019

       Hi John – thanks for reaching out!

       The MaxKare Air Rower is a brand new model so I haven’t done a review on it or spoken to someone who has purchased it. I have not heard of the company before either. Sorry I can’t be over better help but it’s always a roll of the dice when dealing with new models and new companies.

       Reply
42. 

    RJ

    October 24, 2019

    Edwin!

    Any thoughts on the Body Solid Endurance R300? I had a chance to try it and it felt super similar to the C2. Had 9 adjustable settings (1 short of C2). Any thoughts! Looks and feels very similar to the industry standard! Thanks!

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       October 24, 2019

       Hi RJ – thank you for reaching out! I don’t have any experience with the R300 but I will put it on my radar.

       Seems very similar but it appears to only be about $50 less. In my opinion, you would have to compare the warranty and monitors to see if that cost savings is worth it. The Concept2 monitors is one of the key features due to its very high accuracy.

       Reply
    2. 

       Rj

       October 25, 2019

       Thanks dude! R300 is suppose to calculate the same way, that’s why it was intriguing! It looks and feels identical! am getting a better deal than both retail prices so that’s why I was curious!

       Reply
       1. 

          Edwin

          October 26, 2019

          No worries RJ! If you end up buying one, I would love to know your thoughts on how you think the monitors compare!

          Reply
43. 

    Carol

    December 1, 2019

    I am looking to purchase a refurbished Matrix rower….seat rollers have been replaced and I am told the lanyard is in excellent condition. It appears as though it was used commercially. Any red flags I should be looking out for? Asking price is $500. Your site was very informative. Thanks

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       December 1, 2019

       Hi Carol – thanks for reaching out! It’s tough to say how much use a rower got in a commercial setting but $500 for a Matrix Rower is a great deal.

       I would just make sure there is some type of warranty or test period. You can also check to see if the warranty will transfer to your name.

       One question I would ask is why are they selling it? That answer should make sense and hopefully not throw up any red flags.

       Reply
44. 

    Mary

    December 4, 2019

    Hi! Any comments in the Domyos 500 rowing machine from Decathlon?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       December 4, 2019

       Hi Mary – thanks for reaching out!

       Sorry, I don’t have any experience with this model or brand. I do like Decathalon and they usually have high quality, lower cost products. I’d see if you can buy it from the store and return it within 30-days – no questions asked. This way you can test it without any risk.

       Reply
45. 

    John

    March 8, 2020

    Which of the budget towers (under 400) provides the most resistance?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       March 9, 2020

       Hi John – The Sunny Health & Fitness Ultra Tension Pro (SF-RW5508) sells for around $400. It’s going to have additional resistance strength compared to other models in this price range.

       Reply
46. 

    Ken

    February 24, 2021

    Which Rower can support 300 lbs and is quiet while also providing lots of resistance? I am looking at the Hydrow, Octane Ro and Bodycraft.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       February 27, 2021

       Hi Ken – most of the rowers above $500 can support 300lbs. It looks like you are looking in the upper price range so those are all great options.

       The WaterRower brand is great water resistance rowers. Concept2 and Xebex are great air rowers. The Sole SR500 and BodyCraft are great air/magnetic rowers.

       Reply
47. 

    Jessica

    February 26, 2021

    Hi. I’ve been looking at rowing machines for a while. I’m 30, work full time, and often parent our 3 boys (6, 5, 2) on my own while hubs is out of town for work (tradesman). Time is hard to find so I need something at home that gives a larger benefit (strength and cardio) without the bulk of a thousand types of machinery.
    As I’ve never used a rowing machine I’m doing my best to weed down the options out there and understand perks/downsides.
    Currently I’m considering the Fitness Reality 1000 and the ShareVgo Smart Home Towing Machine (do not see on your list but a friend purchased and is happy with it so far). I’m also considering the Merax Magnetic.
    Preferably I’d like a model that has an app associated that includes “training” though I relaize may have additional fee (Merax does not offer?). (I believe this will help with motivation and overall end effort in pushing myself)
    Proform/Nordiktrac offer but for a beginner/first timer that is certainly out of my budget.
    Goals are weight loss and toning. Again, mom of 3, sedentary job, out of shape and overweight and under $300!
    Suggestions?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       February 27, 2021

       Hi Jessica – all of the models you mentioned would be great. Once you narrow it down to a price and resistance type, a lot of the rowers are very similar. I would probably go with the Fitness Reality 1000, it has great reviews and it allows the handle to go further in front of your feet than the ShareVgo Smart Home Towing Machine. If you sit on the floor and mimic a rowing motion, you will see that you really don’t want the handle stopping right where your feet are.

       You can also check out my rowing machine app article for some ideas on different apps to use.

       Reply
48. 

    Michael Wadleigh

    March 11, 2021

    Here’s the situation. I purchased an Echelon rower. I need to know a comparison for 2 different workouts. On the echelon, I rowed 21:46 and went 2077 meters with an output of 269 and 31 SPM. Resistance was set on 20/32. On a previous row on a concept 2, I rowed 23:43 and went 5017 meter also with a 31SPM. Resistance was on 5/10. My question is, can it be assumed that what I row on the echelon rower will be doubled on the concept 2?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       March 13, 2021

       Hey Michael – thank you for reaching out! Trying to do an apples-to-apples comparison of workouts on 2 different rowers is going to be very difficult. You would have to do multiple tests on each rower with the exact same variables on each workout to get an accurate comparison. My guess is you can probably get close to having a rough comparison between the 2 with a few more tests but it won’t be entirely accurate.

       The Concept2 is going to have the most accurate times because of the technology used. The monitor actually self-calibrates by recalculating the drag factor on every pull. It can even recalibrate for changes in humidity and elevation. Elevation has a large impact on air density and therefore drag factor. The monitor will accurately detect environmental changes and adjust the drag factor to assure accurate data.

       So while you may be able to get a good feel for how the 2 monitors compare, it probably won’t be a perfect comparison.

       Reply
49. 

    Ron

    July 14, 2021

    Hi Edwin,

    Came across this website in my hunt for a good rower (been on the prowl for a couple years, on and off). I appreciate all of the detailed reviews you provide.

    One model that I came across, but haven’t seen much press about is the Horizon Oxford 6. This model is magnetic, so has the benefit of being quiet, but has a drive belt instead of a chain.

    Ultimately, the price range for the Oxford 6 is in-line with the Concept 2 (obvious gold standard).

    I’m planning on using the rower about 5 days a week, for around 20-60 min. So a big concern is the longevity of the rower, given the investment (800-1000).

    I plan to give the Horizon Oxford a test run in the coming weeks, as I’ve used a Concept 2 at a gym before and feel that I reasonably know what to expect.

    Wondering if you’ve seen the Horizon Oxford in action and have any thoughts on the durability, etc.

    Thanks!
    Ron

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 14, 2021

       Hi Ron! Thanks for reaching out! Sorry but I have not done any research on the Oxford 6 Rower. I will add it to my list :)

       Your best bet is to test it out like you mentioned. We’d love to hear your feedback if you are able to test it!

       Reply
       1. 

          Ron

          July 15, 2021

          Hi Edwin,

          Thanks for the reply – I’ll get back to this thread with my thoughts on the Oxford 6 rower after I have a chance to check it out.

          Also found an Endurance R300 for a really good price locally, so will give that a ride too.

          Appreciate the reply!
          Ron

          Reply
          1. 

             Ron

             July 19, 2021

             Hi Edwin,

             I had a chance to check out the Horizon Oxford 6 Rower over the weekend.

             As expected, it’s a smooth and quiet ride, given its magnetic resistance. The salesperson I spoke to (won’t mention his name, but if you’re in the Midwest US, you can check out where it’s sold) was fairly knowledgeable and gave me an opportunity to get a decent ride in.

             My concerns still stood – was a belt driven system more reliable long-term versus chain (given my inbound comparison to the Concept 2).

             The points of reference the salesperson could relay: a chain system requires more upkeep (lubricants, etc.), the only drive systems he’s ever seen have problems are chain drives (usually due to poor upkeep and commercial use), and the $2500 water rower next to the Oxford 6 used a nylon cable drive. “So do you really think a machine that expensive would rely on an inferior technology?”

             To me that’s like saying “A Mercedes has a rear window made of glass – do you think they would put a glass window on an expensive car like this if it wasn’t the best?” (To draw the analogy to a finer point, most cars have glass windows, even significantly less expensive brands… that doesn’t necessarily make it the best technology.)

             Anyway, to draw this long reply to a close, as mentioned above, I ended up finding an Endurance R300 for sale locally for $600. I read your review of the machine and felt it was comparable enough to a Concept 2 for my needs.

             This particular bargain was a “floor model”. However, in this case, it was actually a fully-assembled (but completely unused) customer return. The location already had a floor model in-store with no need for a second one. Cutting their losses ended up being my gain!

             The R300 is a solid machine and – while it lacks in some of the bells and whistles of other rowers – for the price, it was too good to pass up.

             Thanks again for the correspondence and all of the content on here. Looking forward to getting in a lot more sessions with my new rower!

             Ron

             Reply
             1. 

                Edwin

                July 23, 2021

                Hi Ron – we really appreciate the detailed reply! Thank you so much for that feedback. I really hope you enjoy the R300!!

                Thanks again

50. 

    Clark Armor

    August 15, 2021

    I’m comparing the Inspire Cross Rower and a Teeter Cross Rower. The Teeter is half the price, which is a huge plus. Worried about the cons between the two. Have you reviewed the Teeter? I appreciate your review on the Inspire CR2. Thanks!

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       August 16, 2021

       Hi Clark! Sorry, I have not had a chance to review the Teeter Cross Rower. I wouldn’t want to give you incorrect information but hopefully I can get to review it soon!

       Reply
51. 

    Edward Smith

    September 14, 2021

    Are there any rowing machines (monitors) that will connect to my Fitbit Versa 3 watch for heart rate readings as opposed to getting the chest strap?

    Reply
52. 

    Mac

    April 24, 2022

    i spoke with manufacturer of Schwinn Crewmaster who said the stopped making it in 2019. What do you think of durability of the product compared to concept 2 and would you expect problems getting parts?

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 20, 2022

       Hi Mac – I think the Concept2 would be better quality and easier to get parts. If you have the money I would choose the Concept2.

       Reply
53. 

    Nick

    June 7, 2022

    A friend recently purchased a life fitness heat rower. It uses a combination of magnetic and air resistance. The heat rower does appear to be well built, and it uses a chain drive.
    However, it is very expensive even when compared to the concept C and the waterrower. Do you have any plans to review one of these?
    A review would be helpful, as these rowers do not appear to be that common.

    Reply
    1. 

       Edwin

       July 20, 2022

       Hi Nick – thanks for reaching out! There are so many new rowers coming out it’s very hard to keep up. I will keep this model on my radar though!

       Reply